Why Retain? Retention and Reading Problems

The Real Issue: Reading
If your child could have learned to read with the type and level of instruction he is currently receiving, he would have already learned to read.

The principal, who says retention is beneficial, is just attempting to take the focus off the real issue. Your child has not learned to read even after several tiers of increased intensity of instruction.
1. You should copy the National Association of School Psychologist's (NASP) position statement on grade retention to clarify the retention discussion.
2. Write a letter requesting a complete evaluation to determine if your child has a disability.

Go to this Parent Information Center website to find sample letter requesting an evaluation. On the left hand column, click on "Special Education" and then click on "Sample Letters."
Read Sue Whitney's article Why Retain? It Didn't Work the First Time.
Co-author of Wrightslaw: No Child Left Behind, Sue Whitney writes Doing Your Homework, a series of articles about reading, research based instruction, school improvement, and creative advocacy strategies.
back to the top

________________________________________
The Definition of Reading
The term 'reading' means a complex system of deriving meaning from print that requires all of the following:
(A) The skills and knowledge to understand how phonemes, or speech sounds, are connected to print.
(B) The ability to decode unfamiliar words.
(C) The ability to read fluently.
(D) Sufficient background information and vocabulary to foster reading comprehension.
(E) The development of appropriate active strategies to construct meaning from print.
(F) The development and maintenance of a motivation to read.
20 U.S.C. § 6368 (5) Wrightslaw: No Child Left Behind, p. 241.
Reading Resources
Florida Center for Reading Research
http://www.fcrr.org/

This is information on what an appropriate reading evaluation should contain.

The National Center for Learning Disabilities has an excellent checklist to use to refine your concerns and to help you ask the referral team to investigate all areas of concern.

The American Federation of Teachers website has an excellent article about the need to avoid delay in getting appropriate instruction, Preventing Early Reading Failure.

Framework for Informed Reading and Language Instruction: Matrix of Multisensory Structured Language Programs. This publication from the International Dyslexia Association explains different reading programs and what they cover. These programs, when properly implemented, have been successful in teaching students to read, write, and use language.
4 Great Definitions of Reading in No Child Left Behind
Reading at Wrightslaw

back to the top

________________________________________
Don't Allow the School to Retain Your Child
The principal is incorrect. Research does not indicate there are benefits to retention.
Retention is not an appropriate intervention. There is clear evidence that retention does not work - and that it damages children.
Review the article "Waiting to fail" Instead of Teaching a Child to Read.
Insist that the school use a research based reading program that is implemented by a highly skilled, trained reading teacher.
If you are dealing with a retention problem, you must educate yourself before you can advocate for the child. Download and read these articles at Retention and Social Promotion.

back to the top

________________________________________
Sample Letter to Request the School NOT Retain Your Child
This sample letter describes a parents' concerns about the school's proposal to retain their child.
The tone of the letter is polite and businesslike. The letter does not blame school personnel or criticize. Instead, the parents describe their concerns about their child's lack of progress, their concerns about the school's proposal to retain her, and propose a solution to the child's problems.
It is an example of how you can use story-telling in letters that document events and describe your concerns. The parents sent this letter after the school proposed to retain their child.
From the sample letter:
"I am unaware of any research that states children with reading disabilities benefit from grade repetition."
"The decision of Placement is a “team” decision, not the decision of one person. It is my understanding that one person cannot make a unilateral decision outside of the team process."
"Although I am opposed to retaining Emma in first grade, I welcome the opportunity to meet with the special education team to learn how the District proposes to provide Emma more intensive services to remediate her reading deficits and/or the possibility of an alternative educational setting which would enable Emma to progress and master the general educational curriculum while receiving intensive instruction to close the gap between her and her nondisabled peers...."
Download a copy of the Sample Retention Letter.
More about advocacy through Writing Letters.